NYPD officer Gilberto Valle rose to infamy after being convicted for conspiring to kidnap, rape, kill and eat several women. Valle, “The Cannibal Cop” was now looking at a life sentence for his Internet searches and online activities. His sexual fantasies cost him his family, his job, and his freedom–but it also prompted a fundamental question: can you be guilty of a crime you only thought of committing? Erin Lee Carr takes a gritty look into the darkest corners of the human psyche. With exclusive access to Valle and his family, Carr challenges our beliefs about the criminal justice system especially as it applies to the ever-evolving digital platform. When it comes to the Internet, how do you draw the line between fantasy and reality? At what point are the desires of a potentially dangerous man criminal? And how do you know when that line has been crossed?
Length: 82 minutes
Director: Erin Lee Carr
Producer: Andrew Rossi
Editor: Andrew Coffman
Associate Producer: Alison Byrne
Cinematographer: Bryan Sarkinen
Executive Producer: Sheila Nevins
Composer: Ian Hultquist
Co-Producer: Andrew Coffman
Supervising Producer: Sara Bernstein
Cast: Gilberto Valle, Gilberto Valle Sr., Elizabeth Valle, Alan Dershowitz, Dr. Michael Welner, Laurie Penny, Erin Murphy, James A. Cohen, Dr. Chris Kraft
Erin Lee Carr has been exploring the intersection between the internet and crime since she began working at VICE media in 2010. In 2013 her film Click. Print. Gun. won a 2014 Webby for best individual short. Thought Crimes is her feature documentary directorial debut.