
BY KAREN KEMMERLE |
Tribeca’s Alternative Oscars
Did a film or performance achieve some distinction (for good or ill) that you feel deserves recognition? We agree, and to rectify the situation, we offer up our choices for Tribeca’s First Annual Alternative Oscars.

While the Oscars are no doubt Hollywood’s most coveted prize, we can’t help but think of all the noteworthy films and performances that are not being recognized by the Academy. With tongue in cheek (but seriously too), we take a look some alternative categories that recognized (and call out) some unlikely films and performances of both the legitimate and dubious variety.
Most Woefully Overlooked Performance of the Year
James Badge Dale as Gaunt Young Man in Flight
Dane DeHaan as Andrew Detmer in Chronicle
Gina Gershon as Sharla Smith in Killer Joe
Marin Ireland as Woman in 28 Hotel Rooms
Nate Parker as Jimmy Grant in Arbitrage
Best Supporting Performance by a Male Playing a Low Life in Killing Them Softly
James Gandolfini as Mickey (the deranged hitman)
Richard Jenkins as Driver (the ultimate middle man)
Ray Liotta as Markie Trattman (the unfortunate patsy)
Scoot McNairy as Frankie (the doomed thief)
Ben Mendelsohn as Russell (the drugged out dog snatcher)
Best Supporting Performance by Females of All Ilks in Pitch Perfect
Elizabeth Banks as Gail (Acapella commentator extraordinaire)
Anna Camp as Aubrey (the wannabe HBIC)
Hana Mae Lee as Lilly (the shy scene stealer)
Brittany Snow as Chloe (the girl with unfortunate vocal chords)
Rebel Wilson as Fat Amy (the real HBIC)
Best Undead Performance
Kate Beckinsale as Selene in Underworld: The Awakening
Dominic Cooper as Henry Strugess in Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter
Johnny Depp as Barnabas Collins in Dark Shadows
Lee Pace as Garrett in The Twlight Sage: Breaking Dawn: Part 2
Sylvester Stallone as Barney Ross in The Expendables 2
Best Performance by an Animal(s)
Fritz and Tony (the horses) in Django Unchained
Richard Parker (the tiger) in Life of Pi
The killer whales in Rust & Bone
Boonee the dog in Starlet
Joaquin Phoenix in The Master
The “Move Over, Quvenzhane Wallis” Award
Shannon Beer as Young Cathy in Wuthering Heights
Jules Brown as Flik Royale in Red Hook Summer
Pierce Gagnon as Cid in Looper
Rachel Mwanza as Komona in War Witch
Armand Verdure as Sam in Rust & Bone
Most Ridiculous Casting Of The Year
Elizabeth Banks as a police negotiator in Man on a Ledge
Nicolas Cage as a high school English teacher in Seeking Justice
Eddie Murphy as a literary agent in A Thousand Words
Robert Pattinson as a billionaire asset manager in Cosmopolis
Rihanna as a naval weapons officer in Battleship
Most Spot-On Casting of the Year
Drew Barrymore as a Greenpeace volunteer in Big Miracle
Chris Hemworth as a God in The Avengers
Robert Pattinson as a prostitute in Bel Ami
Jordin Sparks as a singer/songwriter in Sparkle
Channing Tatum as a male stripper in Magic Mike
Most Unhinged Police Officer
Michael Shannon as Bobby Monday in Premium Rush
Jake Gyllenhaal & Michael Pena as Brian Taylor & Mike Zavala in End of Watch
John Travolta as Dennis in Savages
Jay R. Ferguson as Keith Clayton in The Lucky One
Karl Urban as Judge Dredd in Dredd
Best Musical Number
Jack Black’s performance of 76 Trombones in Bernie
The Cast of Damsels in Distress do The Sambola in Damsels in Distress
Mark Duplass singing Big Machine in Safety Not Guaranteed
Matthew McConaughey’s striptease to Calling Dr. Love in Magic Mike
Catherine Zeta-Jones’ performance of Hit Me With Your Best Shot in Rock of Ages
Most Complete Waste of Time By an Entire Ensemble Cast (and its entire audience)
Prometheus
Seeking A Friend for the End of The World
That’s My Boy
This Means War
Total Recall
Best Reason to Weep for Future Generations
Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Dog Days
Fun Size
LOL
Project X
Step Up Revolution
More from Tribeca:
Ranking the Top Movie-Star Ads During the Oscars
Oscar Snubbed but Not Forgotten: The Renaissance of Matthew McConaughey